I am honestly torn on the issue of online classes, particularly in the K-12 arena. I love the possibilities of online courses and know that there are a lot of resources available to create engaging and interesting online classes. The textbook publishers have developed online interactive content, that I have used with my son in Algebra that is helpful and high quality.Even though some great courses exist, I do not think the average high school student would thrive in the online environment that is currently available. Most do not have the maturity and motivation to be successful in the existing environment.
The predominant curriculum that is readily available today is in the cyber-school arena. The students are given all of the materials they need and are expected to work through the course in a sequential manner. It is primarily independent study with parental guidance and teacher input. My niece completed a semester of cyber-school in 8th grade and she is an above average student and able to work independently with good reading comprehension. She only completed one semester because she did not like having to do all of the work on her own. She missed the classroom discussions and interaction with the teacher and her peers. If students turning to cyber-school are the students who have to make up credits in order to graduate, they are most likely already not highly motivated students and will have difficulty taking the responsibility to succeed. I recently had a student transfer from cyber-school back to high school join my accounting class. He did two assignments for the whole marking period in his cyber-school accounting class and was coming into my class without the foundation of knowledge to be successful. He is absent more than he is in class, and while he needs the class to graduate in June, he remains unmotivated. To be successful in an online course, a student needs to be able to work independently and be motivated.
I also believe that there is a lot to gain from the traditional classroom setting , in terms of communication and social skills. In the traditional classroom students learn to control their impulses, express themselves, and how to get along with other people. These skills are essential to success in life and in the workplace, and moving to an online curriculum will reduce the amount of time the students have to develop these skills. School is a great place to practice having conversations and being respectful of other people's views and opinions. Every day for six hours students have to interact with people and learn to express themselves effectively. It allows the student to realize that they are not the center of the universe and their actions and reactions affect the people around them.
The final reason that I believe that young learners would benefit from traditional classrooms is to develop the skills and maturity needed to learn effectively online. One of the authors in the article that the students do not know how to effectively utilize the online environment for learning and they need to be taught how to make the most of it. I agree that there is a skill set that is required for learning online and the skills can be taught and learned. I think the best approach would be to phase in online learning and have students develop their skills in working more independently. It would be a mistake to expect someone to start online course without any overview and instruction. I know when I came back to school for my masters, it was a whole new world. I had taken online courses through the workplace, but Blackboard and Bolt were a whole new experience for me. There was very little information about how to log in and get ids on the Bloomsburg system, that I can remember a bunch of us talking the first night of class trying to figure out where to find your pin and system id. Picking up technology is more challenging for some people than others, and to insure success for online learners, there needs to be an introductory class, to allow students to know what they are getting into.
In general, I like online classes and feel they can be effective. However, I do not think they should be used for all courses and topics and the coursework and material needed to be taken into account when planning. The students' skill levels, independence, and maturity also are key factors in successful online learning. I am looking forward to seeing the growth in online courses, especially with the development of more interactive technology.

It is weird, I did not have to enter a "secret code" to post today.
ReplyDelete